Can I Replace Half of My Roof? 6 Things To Have In Mind

Your roof is one of the most critical parts of your home, and keeping it in good condition is essential.

Unfortunately, sometimes, roofs can be damaged and need to be repaired or replaced. If you are facing this situation, you may wonder if you can replace just half of your roof.

The answer is, generally speaking, no. There are six main reasons why replacing half of your roof is not advisable. Let’s explore those reasons so you can better understand why it’s better to replace your whole roof at once.

1. Your Roof Is Designed To Function as a Unit

All of the components of your roof work together as a unit to protect your home from the elements. If you replace just half of your roof, you will have two different types of materials on the roof.

Doing this can create problems including:

  • Different materials may not expand and contract at the same rate, which can cause problems with the sealant between them.
  • Different materials may have different warranties, making it difficult to get your roof covered if something goes wrong.
  • Different materials may age at different rates, meaning one side of your roof could fail long before the other.

It’s much better to replace your entire roof with materials designed to work together. Doing this will ensure that your roof functions properly and lasts for as long as possible.

2. You Could Void Your Roofing Warranty

Another reason to avoid replacing just half of your roof is that you could void your roofing warranty. Most roofing manufacturers will only warranty their products if installed correctly, which generally means replacing your whole roof.

If you replace just half of your roof, you could void the warranty on both new and existing materials. Doing this could leave you on the hook for any repairs or replacement costs down the road.

In addition, your insurance company may not cover damages if your roof is not installed according to the manufacturer’s specifications.

Replacing your whole roof will ensure that your warranty remains valid and that you have coverage for future problems.

3. It’s More Difficult (and More Expensive) to Match Materials

If you’re thinking about replacing just half of your roof, one of the challenges you’ll face is finding materials that match the existing materials on your roof. Roofing materials can vary widely in color, texture, and thickness, and it can be hard to find an exact match.

Even if you can find matching materials, they may not be available in the exact quantities as the existing materials, making your roofing project more expensive and complicated than it needs to be.

It’s much easier to replace your whole roof with new, uniform material. This consistent material will give your home a clean, finished look. Matching materials is especially difficult if a lot of time has passed since you first replaced your roof.

4. You Might Need To Reinforce Your Roof Structure

Another potential problem with replacing just half of your roof is that you might need to reinforce your roof structure because removing the old roofing materials can weaken your roof structure.

If you don’t reinforce your roof correctly, it could collapse under the weight of the new materials, which could cause serious injuries or even death. In addition, a collapsed roof can cause extensive damage to your home.

Replacing your whole roof will ensure that your roof structure is strong enough to support the new materials. Doing this will help to avoid any accidents or damage to your home. You won’t have to worry about safety issues that could create problems down the road.

5. It’s More Difficult To Install Ventilation When Replacing Half of a Roof

One of the most critical components of a roof is the ventilation system. This system helps to keep your attic cool in the summer and prevents moisture from building up inside your home.

If you’re replacing just half of your roof, installing the ventilation system properly won’t be easy. 

If you don’t install this system appropriately, you could face many problems, including:

  • Your attic could get too hot in the summer, leading to higher energy bills.
  • Moisture could build up in your attic, leading to mold and mildew.
  • Your roof could rot from the inside out, leading to expensive repairs.

Replacing your whole roof will ensure that your ventilation system is installed correctly and your home is protected from the elements no matter what time of year.

6. Doing One Side Doesn’t Look Good

Last but not least, it’s essential to consider the aesthetics of your home. For example, if you replace just half of your roof, the two sides will likely look different, giving your home an unfinished or unbalanced appearance.

That is because one side will look newer while the other will be faded and sun-bleached. If you try to sell your house with a roof like this, you may receive questions from potential home buyers about it, hindering the sale.

In addition, if you have a shingled roof, replacing just half of the shingles can be difficult because the new shingles will need to be cut to fit the existing shingles. Doing this can create a patchwork appearance that is unsightly and difficult to repair.

Wrap Up

In conclusion, replacing just half of your roof is generally not advisable and could lead to spending even more money in the long run.

Replacing your whole roof will ensure that your roofing warranty remains valid, that you’re covered in case future problems crop up, and that your home looks its best.

In addition, by taking the time to replace your whole roof, you’ll enjoy peace of mind and a beautiful home for years to come without having to worry about expensive repairs.

Finally, contact a qualified roofing contractor if you have any questions about whether or not you should replace your whole roof. One of our roof experts will be able to assess your situation and give you the best advice for your home. Contact us today.

Latest Posts

Working through Covid-19. 100% Online or Phone Consultations. 100% Financing.